Williamsburg: Ghosts, Witches & Pirates Night Walking Tour

Summary

Colonial streets echo with ghost tales pirates and witch trials

You’ll walk Williamsburg’s shadowy streets hearing true stories of ghosts, pirates, and witches from your local guide. Stand where Blackbeard’s crew met their fate, try saying Grace Sherwood’s name (good luck), and finish at Jones Graveyard where silence feels heavier than usual. Includes wheelchair accessibility and no historic area ticket needed—a night you’ll remember long after.

What’s the experience like?

The first thing I noticed was the way the gas lamps flickered along Duke of Gloucester Street in Williamsburg—like they were trying to tell their own secrets. Our guide, Mary, had this old brass lantern that squeaked a little every time she turned. She grinned when someone asked if she’d ever seen a ghost herself (“not yet, but Ida Jones keeps me guessing”). There was this mix of cool night air and something sweet from a bakery still open nearby. I kept catching whiffs of cinnamon or maybe nutmeg as we stopped outside the Peyton Randolph House. People say it’s the most haunted place in America—I didn’t expect to feel anything, but honestly, standing there in the dark with the shutters drawn tight, my skin prickled anyway.

Mary told us about Blackbeard’s crew getting hanged right here, and how some folks used to drink from his skull (I mean… who thinks of that?). She had this way of making it all sound like it happened last week instead of centuries ago. We all tried saying “Grace Sherwood” like locals do—Li laughed when I tried to say it in a Virginia accent; probably butchered it. Turns out Grace was called the Witch of Pungo and finally got pardoned after 300 years. The Capitol building looked different at night—shadows everywhere—and for a second I thought I saw someone move behind one of the columns. Maybe just my imagination running wild after so many ghost stories.

The part that stuck with me was at Jones Graveyard. It was quieter there than anywhere else on the tour—no car sounds, just our footsteps on gravel and someone’s phone buzzing by accident (they fumbled to silence it). Mary lowered her voice as she talked about Ida Jones haunting these graves. I caught myself holding my breath without meaning to. At the end, Mr. Pirate showed up for the kids—he even opened a little chest for them to grab “treasure.” It felt like everyone loosened up then; even adults smiled like they were kids again for a second. I still think about that hush in the graveyard though—you know?

Step-by-step itinerary

Day 1 — Explore Williamsburg's haunted history

• Visit haunted colonial sites
• Learn about Blackbeard's crew hangings
• Hear story of Blackbeard's skull
• Stand at Grace Sherwood's trial site
• Discover Grace Sherwood's fate
• Learn about Anne Bonny and Mary Reed
• Visit Jones Graveyard at night
• Hear about Ida Jones haunting

Top questions

Is this Williamsburg Ghosts Witches & Pirates Tour suitable for kids?

Yes, children are welcome and even receive small treasures at the end from Mr. Pirate.

Do I need an admission ticket to Colonial Williamsburg for this tour?

No admission ticket is required for this walking tour experience.

Is the tour wheelchair accessible?

Yes, all areas and surfaces are wheelchair accessible throughout the tour.

How long does the Ghosts Witches & Pirates Tour last?

The exact duration isn’t specified but expect an evening walking tour with several stops.

Are service animals allowed on this Williamsburg ghost tour?

Yes, service animals are allowed during the tour.

Does this tour include stories about real historical figures?

Yes, you’ll hear researched stories about people like Blackbeard and Grace Sherwood.

Is transportation provided or needed for this tour?

No transportation is provided; public transport options are available nearby if needed.

What’s included

Your evening includes fully guided storytelling through Colonial Williamsburg’s haunted sites with no historic area admission required; wheelchair access throughout; families can bring strollers or prams; service animals are welcome; plus a fun treasure moment at the end for kids—all while staying safe and aware on these historic streets.