Brooklyn Pizza Crawl: Four Slices and Local Brews

Four different pizzeria styles in one afternoon, plus the breweries that pair them

The Brooklyn Pizza Crawl is a small group pizza tasting in Williamsburg where you eat four slices from different pizzerias (each with its own technique, from gas oven to coal-fired) guided by a local foodie. The group stays under 10 for a personalized experience, and you can add two beers from local breweries or a four-sample guided tasting at Brooklyn Brewery to finish the afternoon.

Step-by-step itinerary

Stops and time at each

1. Bedford Avenue30m · entry included
2. Williamsburg10m · entry included
3. Brooklyn Brewery30m · entry included

Brooklyn pizza tasting and brews

• Meet guide at Williamsburg Pizza
• Eat classic New York slice
• Enjoy sweet treat with alcohol
• Drink beer at Brooklyn beer garden
• Taste old-school Italian New York slice
• Visit brick oven neighborhood pizzeria
• Sample local beer and learn brewing

The experience

You meet your guide at Williamsburg Pizza, known for crisp and buttery square grandma pies, and that's your first stop. From there you move through the neighborhood hitting three more pizzerias: a classic no-frills New York slice shop on Bedford Avenue that's been serving the same way for decades; a third stop that brings old-school Italian pizza making to the New York style; and a brick oven place that takes the neighborhood slice shop into the 21st century. Each one has its own approach, so you're tasting the range of what Brooklyn pizza actually is, not a curated highlight reel.

The crawl runs three hours and you'll have more than enough to eat. Come hungry. Your guide is a local foodie who hands you a digital map full of their own recommendations for the rest of your time in Brooklyn, so you leave with more than just the four slices. The group caps at 10, which means you're not herded through with thirty other people. It's small enough that the guide can actually talk to you about what you're eating and why each place does it differently.

If you add the brews option, you get two beers from local breweries as part of the afternoon: one at the original beer garden, one at Brooklyn Brewery at the end. Without it, you finish at the brewery and can order on your own. The whole thing is two subway stops from Manhattan, so it's an easy afternoon if you've got a few hours free and want to eat your way through one neighborhood instead of walking it.

What’s included

• Four slices of pizza, each from a different pizzeria with its own style.
• a local foodie guide leading a small group capped at 10.
• a digital map with your guide's recommendations for the rest of Brooklyn.
• two beers from local breweries (if you add the brews option) or a four-sample guided tasting at Brooklyn Brewery (if you choose that add-on instead).

Options for this experience

4 options

A local pizza tour in BrooklynGuide in English · 13:00 and 14:00

Tour with an add-on for brewsGuide in English · 13:00 and 14:00Brews Add-On: A boozy dessert and two beers

Private TourGuide in English · Available from 22 Oct 2027Private tour

Private tour with Brews Add-OnGuide in English · Available from 22 Oct 2027Brews Add-On: Private tour that includes two beers and a boozy dessert

You see the exact price of each option when you check availability.See dates & prices

Before you book

Days and timesThursday to SaturdayDepartures at 13:00 and 14:00

Book up to1h before

GroupUp to 15

Live guideEnglish

Meeting point and pickupNo hotel pickup: you go to the meeting point. Ends at a different place from where it starts.

Cancellation and refundsFree cancellation up to 24 h before the start. After that, no refund.

ConfirmationConfirmation within 48h

Prices and times updated yesterday

Good to know

Easy physical levelWheelchair accessibleAccessible transportStroller friendlyPets welcomePublic transport nearby

Operated by Unscripted Tours

Is this one for you?Choose the brews add-on if you want to pair the pizza with local beer and learn about Brooklyn's brewing scene; pick the private tour if you'd rather move through the pizzerias with just your group instead of mixing with others; or book the standard tour if you want the full small-group experience at the base price.

Traveler reviews

5.00★★★★★★★★★★

12 verified traveler reviews

Read all the reviews ›

Top questions

What's the difference between the four pizzerias on this crawl?

Each pizzeria has its own style: Williamsburg Pizza makes crisp square grandma pies; one serves classic no-frills New York slices the traditional way; a third brings old-school Italian technique to the New York slice; and the last uses a brick oven to blend neighborhood tradition with modern execution. You taste all four approaches in one afternoon.

Can I do this as a private tour instead of a small group?

Yes, private tours are available. You can book a private tour with or without the brews add-on, so you choose whether to include the local beers at the end.

How much pizza will I actually eat?

You get four slices total, one from each pizzeria, and the operator notes you'll have more than enough to fill you up. Come hungry.

Is the brews add-on worth it, or can I skip it?

The brews add-on includes two beers from local breweries as part of your afternoon: one at the beer garden and one at Brooklyn Brewery. Without it, you finish at the brewery and can order drinks separately. You also have the option to do a four-sample guided tasting at Brooklyn Brewery instead.

How do I get to Williamsburg from Manhattan?

Williamsburg is two subway stops from Manhattan, so it's a quick and easy trip. Public transportation options are available near the meeting point.